Wednesday, April 23, 2025

RE: Public Comment: Case #2024-00326 Case No. 2024-00326 Thank you for your comments on the application of Kentucky Utilities Company, Louisville Gas and Electric Company. Your comments in the above‐referenced matter have been received and will be placed into the case file for the Commission’s consideration. Please cite the case number in this matter, 2024-00326, in any further correspondence. The documents in this case are available at View Case Filings for: 2024-00326 (ky.gov). Thank you for your interest in this matter. From: Maggie Hettinger Sent: Wednesday, April 23, 2025 1:46 PM To: PSC Public Comment Subject

: Public Comment: Case #2024-00326

Dear Public Service Commission, Maggie Hettinger mhettinger@mac.com , 131 E Pioneer Ct., Lebanon Junction, KY, US, 40150-8214 hysteria is not a reason to abandon renewable energy progress and promise. all of a sudden data centers and AI want

Dear Public Service Commission,


hysteria is not a reason to abandon renewable energy progress and promise.

all of a sudden data centers and AI want to use as much power as is available now to the customers and communities who support the existing system.  

And our "leaders" are keen to cash in on the investment, it seems.

but where are the adults in the room?

since AI is so promising, why are we not being responsible by stating  the massive energy required is not available, which is true.  

It just means that AI application has not matured enough to be feasible.

powerful people in the dirty energy cash flow, of course, are happy to have us all line their pockets 

since the Chinese can apparently do AI work with massively less power, I suspect our industry here can do the same, but only if required. 

it actually does matter to all of us humans that we pull down greenhouse gas from the atmosphere.   Doubling the output is not acceptable.  

Fossil fuels are the signature of the selfish.



 

Saturday, April 19, 2025

 https://bernheim.org/news/isaac-wolfe-bernheim-climate-heroes-2025/


ISAAC WOLFE BERNHEIM CLIMATE HEROES 2025

By Mark Wourms

From Worry to Action: How the 2025 Bernheim Climate Heroes Inspire Change

Many of us feel the weight of the climate crisis. We read the headlines, see the impacts, and wonder: What can I do? It’s easy to feel overwhelmed, but Bernheim’s 2025 Isaac W. Bernheim Climate Heroes, Carmel Bowman and Maggie Hettinger, show us that meaningful action is possible for all of us. These two sisters have spent years turning climate concern into climate solutions, proving that individuals can make a profound impact on their communities and beyond.

2025 Climate Heroes, Carmel Bowman and Maggie Hettinger at RESTORE

Leading by Example

Carmel Bowman, based in Nelson County, and Maggie Hettinger, from Bullitt County, don’t just talk about climate action—they live it. Both sisters have integrated sustainability into their daily lives, demonstrating that small, practical choices add up to big change. From installing solar panels and driving electric vehicles to advocating for sustainable policies and engaging their neighbors, they embody the idea that the most effective climate leaders are those who lead by example.

Carmel, an early adopter of solar energy, powers her home sustainably and even sends extra energy back to the grid. She shares her experience through solar home tours, where attendees can test-drive electric vehicles, speak with experts, and leave with tangible ideas for making their own homes more energy efficient. She has also organized commercial solar seminars for businesses and nonprofits, and has taken an active role in protecting local waterways and biodiversity through citizen science.

Maggie, a longtime advocate with the Citizens’ Climate Lobby, educates others through workshops, public speaking, and opinion pieces. She has installed both solar and geothermal systems at her home, uses solar energy to charge her electric vehicle, and engages in direct conversations that help shift community perspectives on climate action.

Moving People from Concern to Action

One of the most remarkable things about these sisters is how they empower others to take action. Climate change can feel like an insurmountable challenge, but Carmel and Maggie break it down into tangible steps anyone can take. They create spaces where people can ask questions, explore solutions, and connect with resources that make sustainable living achievable.

Inspiring Change in Rural Communities

Too often, rural communities are left out of climate conversations. Carmel and Maggie are changing that. They recognize that climate solutions need to be accessible and relevant to everyone, not just those in urban centers. By bringing workshops, advocacy, and real-world examples of sustainable living to their local communities, they ensure that climate action is inclusive and practical for rural Kentuckians.

Their work challenges the misconception that environmentalism is only for big cities. Their leadership demonstrates that meaningful change can happen anywhere—and that every community has a role to play in the fight against climate change. Carmel has also emphasized nonviolent communication in her advocacy, ensuring that climate discussions remain constructive and inclusive, even in politically divided spaces.

A Call to Action: Start Where You Are

If there’s one lesson to take from the work of Carmel Bowman and Maggie Hettinger, it’s this: You don’t have to be a scientist, policymaker, or full-time activist to make a difference. The key is to start where you are, use the tools you have, and take that first step. Maybe it’s switching to renewable energy, speaking up at a town hall meeting, or simply planting native species in your backyard to support local biodiversity. Every action, no matter how small, contributes to a larger movement.

Carmel and Maggie remind us that climate action isn’t about perfection—it’s about participation. Their work proves that when we shift from worry to action, we don’t just help the planet; we build stronger, more connected, and more resilient communities.

Congratulations to the 2025 Bernheim Climate Heroes! May their leadership inspire all of us to take that next step toward a sustainable future.


To discover more about the Isaac Wolfe Bernheim Climate Hero Awards and explore previous recipients, visit our Climate Hero page.

AUTOPOIESIS

All

you


talented, tough, caring and loving people …


Our way of life is off track for a good life.


Please know

Our universe is drawing itself to a higher plane.


If we stand gently strong,

even in the chaos, it will sustain our good actions and thoughts.


Striving to live comfortably within the boundaries of our natural world,

individual action inspires communal awakening.


So, please, continue your searching and seeking, and hold your leaders accountable for doing the same. Every morning. Every day.

Saturday, April 29, 2023

POWERED BY THE SUN Electric vehicle fueled with solar energy

I drive an electric car. It is a 2019 Chevy Bolt that we bought new. I consider it a gift from my Mom, since we used inheritance money to purchase both the car and the solar panels on the roof of our home. That's  a life-changing combination. Thanks, Mom.

My bumper sticker says  

POWERED BY THE SUN

electric vehicle fueled with solar energy

It disturbs me a little when I read that the average new electric vehicle costs $75,000. That's true, but misleading. Some of those EVs are luxury cars at luxury prices. Don't confuse "average" with "usual." 

I don’t have any desire for a $108,700 Hummer EV Pickup, but I have ridden in a Tesla. It was great fun. Still (no offense), to me it was not much different from my Bolt. Both are quiet, smooth, and zippy.  Both have lots of new-tech amenities and safety features. 

Range issues? Not really. 300 miles is plenty. We charge in our garage. Rarely do we charge anywhere else, but back when we did take regular trips to a club in the next state, we just ran a heavy-duty 220 outlet there (like a dryer or RV hookup). 

Road trips can be a little bit of an adventure, checking ahead for charging options, but less so every year, and we know we can always just rent a car if that makes better sense. We used to do that anyway for family trips. 

I mean, do we REALLY need a cross-country caravan vehicle for everyday jaunts to work, school, meetings, or groceries? Nah. 

The Bolt does it all for everyday. The back seats have the easy hooks for grandchildren's car seats, and they just as easily lay over to let me use it as a truck. It's got a good radio that does podcasts and phone and maps and locates public chargers.

A brand-new 2023 Chevy Bolt EV starts at $26,500. That’s before applying EV tax incentives (currently a $7,500 rebate from the federal plan), so you can knock that price down at least somewhere in the $19,000s, maybe lower.   

And, for you "average" EV customers, whoever you might be, for less than that "average" $75,000 you could get JUST a wonderful electric vehicle of your dreams, or you COULD package a less-expensive wonderful EV car with a magical 25-years-of-sunshine-power package! 

Yes, you, too, can be powered by solar energy. Solar panels on your house to charge the house and car? Solar panels on the garage wall? On the garage roof?  Battery storage to even out the load? Battery storage to be a backup for your house? Package your car with a solar-paneled carport for yourself AND your neighbors? Buy into Community Solar through your electric utility or co-op?

That's a lot of lifestyle choice. Trust me, you won't miss having to go to the gas station. 


Friday, April 28, 2023

Amanda Gorman "Earthrise"

 <iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/xwOvBv8RLmo" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" allowfullscreen></iframe>


Amanda Gorman "Earthrise"

Monday, April 17, 2023

When a shoe drops in the forest, is there any sound?

The other shoe has dropped in Bernheim Arboretum and Research Forest. As Friends of Bernheim learned this week, “Bernheim is filing an appeal to the March 31, 2023 Bullitt Circuit Court opinion in the case of Louisville Gas & Electric Company v. Isaac W. Bernheim Foundation and Kentucky Heritage Land Conservation Fund.

 The opinion found that LG&E had the “right to take” the easement that it sought for construction of a 12’’ natural gas pipeline across property owned by Bernheim.”

This was disappointing. Bernheim is taking on the expense of protecting the legal way we protect clean water, endangered species, conservation easements and the vanishing wildlife corridors. We need that.


The other thing that concerns all of us is this new piece of fossil fuel infrastructure being built at all. It will run 12 miles across two counties. When this court case was presented in January, the usually calm and collected LG&E attorney actually sounded emotional about potential gas customers who had been turned down for service in the extended area. Apparently this argument was effective.


What the lawyer didn’t mention in court was how many of those customers still need the pipeline. Both the natural environment and the energy production environment have changed a lot in the intervening time.

 

We might feel nostalgic twinges about the vroom and fumes of gasoline powered engines and propane and gas heat, but households and businesses function very well with electricity. Electric heat is clean and affordable. Electric motors deliver plenty of oomph. Electric appliances work great. The move to tackle climate change has strong support and multiple financial incentives.


Are the people of Bullitt and Nelson Counties going to be saddled with a messy mistake?


As a gas AND electric company, LG&E can choose to get up to speed connecting their customers with efficiency upgrades and improvements while helping people all over the world working furiously to meet very important pollution deadlines. Who better for this job than LG&E? If not now, when? What’s the plan? The judges in the race to hold global warming to 1.5ºC are the laws of physics, and these laws are not swayed by emotion.


In the forsythia bush outside my window, there is a beautiful cardinal, mostly gray with red streaks in her wings and tail, piercing black eyes and a red beak.  All morning, she has been flying into the glass (Bam! Bam!) attacking her %reflection. Hopefully she will give up on this illusion before she comes to harm. 


This seems an apt metaphor for fossil fuel companies still chasing the illusion of never-ending fossil fuel production. They have a choice to re-align their assets and their employees’ skills, expertise and customer base to provide renewable energy to a world that will warmly welcome their service. 


I hope LG&E will heed the urgings of Louisville Metro Council and so many others to redirect its energy into clean energy and let Bernheim continue to do its thing, which it does very well.


References:  
McKibben, B. (2022). The Persistence of Fossil fuels. In Greta Thunberg, The Climate Book (1st ed., Vol. 1, p. 220). Penguin Press. https://theclimatebook.org

Published April 19, The Kentucky Standard

Tuesday, April 11, 2023

Bullitt County Public Schools National ENERGY STAR Partner award, IRA -- LTE to Pioneer News, CJ

I don’t know how many people know this, but we can be proud that Bullitt County Public Schools was awarded a national 2023 ENERGY STAR Partners of the Year Award from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. BCPS reduced energy use by 50% since 2016 and achieved recognition as an ENERGY STAR Certification Nation Premier member by earning the ENERGY STAR for eighteen (18) schools in 2022, and is a Sustained Excellence winner for one year. I think we can all be glad about this, and thank hard-working staff, site-based leadership, and school board members for their effort.

As local trend-setters, the school system is undoubtedly saving taxpayer money on energy bills, providing cleaner air for students in buildings, and making a commendable dent in heat-trapping carbon pollution let loose in Earth’s atmosphere.  


As we come to Earth Day, April 22, there is good news for all of us. The familiar ENERGY STAR label program that helps homeowners with appliances and home heating is being upgraded and expanded as part of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) that passed Congress in fall of last year. This IRA program is coming on line at all levels--for homeowners, renters, commercial buildings, churches and schools--as America sets out on a ten-year plan to, among other things, reduce energy bills, energy use and energy-related pollution by 75% by weatherizing our buildings and upgrading to highly-efficient electric.


I’d like to encourage everyone here to start watching for this in appliance stores and consider what plans you would like to make for yourself. Be aware that financial support is available, probably a lot more than you expect (see rewiringamerica,org/app/ira-calculator), because what we do for ourselves, we are actually doing to improve the lives of all our neighbors and our children’s children.


====================================================================================================


Sources:


Energy use reduction source: rewiringamerica.org  rewiringamerica.org/policy/householdreport graphic    "Annual average energy use per U.S. household, kWh equivalents"



EPA Source:    Email from Environmental Protection Agency via IFTTT

U.S. EPA Honors 2023 ENERGY STAR® Partners of the Year Award Winners in Kentucky

Region 04

FRANKFORT, KY. (March 28, 2023) — The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Region 4 and the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) are honoring four ENERGY STAR partners in Kentucky for their outstanding leadership in promoting energy efficiency and tackling climate change.

“As we accelerate historic efforts to address climate change, public-private partnerships will be essential to realizing the scale of our ambition,” said EPA Administrator Michael S. Regan. “I applaud this year’s ENERGY STAR award winners for working with EPA to deliver a clean energy future that saves American consumers and businesses money and creates jobs.”

“We congratulate our 2023 Energy Star Partners of the Year in R4 States for their leadership and commitment to taking action that will help us leave a healthier planet for future generations,” said EPA Region 4 Administrator Daniel Blackman. “The awardees demonstrate national leadership in cost-saving energy efficient solutions which help benefit communities in the Southeast.”

For more than 30 years, EPA’s ENERGY STAR program has supported the transition to a clean energy economy by fostering innovation, jobs, and economic development, while protecting public health. ENERGY STAR certified products, homes, buildings, and plants helped save American families and businesses more than 520 billion kilowatt-hours of electricity and avoid $42 billion in energy costs in 2020 alone. 

Here are a few examples of how 2023 ENERGY STAR Award Winners in Kentucky are taking action:

  • Shepherdsville, KY - Bullitt County Public Schools, a school district in Kentucky, sustained reductions in energy use of 50% since 2016 and achieved recognition as an ENERGY STAR Certification Nation Premier member by earning the ENERGY STAR for 18 schools in 2022. Sustained Excellence winner for one year.
  • Lexington, KY - Lexmark International, Inc., a global technology company, certified 100% of products introduced in 2022, with over 85% of products earning the ENERGY STAR label.
  • Louisville, KY - Schneider Electric, an energy management and automation services company, submitted nearly 160 buildings for ENERGY STAR certification and benchmarked more than 59,000 properties. Sustained Excellence winner for five years.
  • Georgetown, KY - Scott County Schools, a school district in Kentucky, earned the ENERGY STAR for 12 schools and leveraged ENERGY STAR to engage stakeholders, district officials, custodians, teachers, and students. Sustained Excellence winner for six years.

Read more about the ENERGY STAR Awards and Award Winners’ achievements.

About ENERGY STAR 

ENERGY STAR® is the government-backed symbol for energy efficiency, providing simple, credible, and unbiased information that consumers and businesses rely on to make well-informed decisions. Thousands of industrial, commercial, utility, state, and local organizations rely on their partnership with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to deliver cost-saving energy efficiency solutions. Since 1992, ENERGY STAR and its partners helped American families and businesses avoid more than $500 billion in energy costs and achieve more than 4 billion metric tons of greenhouse gas reductions. More background information about ENERGY STAR’s impacts can be found at www.energystar.gov/impacts

Monday, March 27, 2023

Transition Time 2.0

This coming full moon marks the time people all over the world remember transition--leaving the known for unknown territory. 

We know the story. Moses in a basket, enslavement under Pharaoh, centuries of suffering, unheeded plagues, disease, cataclysmic events. Exodus. Rebellion at Massah and Meribah. Moses led the Israelites out of slavery into a new promised land. Great, right?  

Tradition tells us it didn't start out that way.  

After four centuries of being slaves, the Israelites wouldn't have known how to live independently. Their lives had been all about building pyramids to the wealthy. Life essentials--food and shelter--came from the masters, food probably cooked and distributed at the workplace. They were frightened and confused. And really angry.

To them, traveling the “wilderness” was shockingly impossible. There was no food distribution. They yelled, “Are we going to die here of thirst with our livestock and our children?” 

Moses knew he was likely to get stoned, but with the help of his God, he persisted.

Looooong story short, (behold!) the wilderness of the natural world provided manna, honey, and water from the rock. There WAS food and shelter in that new space, and a civilization to rebuild. The Israelite communities learned to be free again. 

This life-changing reawakening has been retold for three thousand years.

We are at one of those great transitional inflection points right now, and it might not seem so great. The fossil fuel yolk of Earth is behind us now. We have to pass through to a different life. Can we do it well?  Can we free ourselves from the gas pump and the coal mine that have enslaved so many lives in the past and continue to do so today? 

A disturbed Earth is telling us there is no time to waste. Benign wind and sun are ready to support our communities. We have the technology. Thousands of scientists, engineers and planners have worked for years to put it all together for us.  

It’s time. Reach out your hand. 

We are all leaders in some sphere, and it's our chance to do this with grace, compassion and love. Simplify your life, weatherize homes, electrify everything, rebuild community for closeness and intimacy. Revere and restore the natural world. Just find a piece of the puzzle that matters to you and start wherever you live and work.  

There is lots of help. Look at: 
The Climate Book:The Facts and the Solutions -- Greta Thunberg, ed.



Thursday, February 02, 2023

Fingernails, a gas pipeline, and a migration corridor

Fingernails, a gas pipeline, and a migration corridor

As a person who has very recently turned 70, I spend more time than I like visiting funeral homes.  It makes you think.    

Factoid: After a person dies, their hair and fingernails continue growing. 

This is not something I think about a lot, but I’ve heard it all my life. Shocking and scary, but that’s life. I get it.

What I CAN’T grasp is the logic that after I die MY hair and MY fingernails could continue growing, but I’m dead.  My living brain won’t focus on this and slides around the idea in a really funky way.

Psychologists know it’s hard to get our heads around ideas that conflict, especially when they involve survival. Thinking about LG&E-KU’s proposed gas pipeline bulldozing through a protected migration corridor is one of those funky conflicts. 


I live in the same woods as Bernheim Forest and so, I have a particular interest in how that conflict resolution is going, but I didn’t always live here. 


I grew up in a gas-connected neighborhood in Louisville. My great-uncle was the land developer. 


The entrance to Willmar Avenue was distinguished by two brightly lit gas lanterns, and we cooked on a gas stove and had not one, but two gas furnaces in our basement. Natural gas absolutely provided a tangible improvement over coal, kerosene or wood heating. Louisville Gas & Electric infrastructure was something we took for granted, but I do recall gas commercials on a black-and-white TV set.


Now I live in a different place and time where conservation of natural resources is obviously not keeping pace with land development. Bernheim Forest’s Cedar Grove Wildlife Corridor shores up a dangerously weak point in migration between forests to the north and the great Daniel Boone and Appalachian forests south and east. The value of protecting and enhancing that disputed bit of a wildlife corridor is clear as day to some people and invisible to others. I see that. Again, it’s life.


I am a person who knows that I and my life-support systems need to immediately change course to use clean energy. Our country and the world are aiming for a target of reducing carbon emissions (the ones that are propelling and intensifying extreme weather).  The target is net zero emissions by 2050. Net zero means completely negating the amount of greenhouse gases produced by human activity. In order to do that, we have known for over a decade that we can and must reach a halfway point by 2030. 


2030. 


Seven. Years. From. Now. 


Lives depend on this, but as communities, we are all having a hard time coming to grips with scary and conflicting levels of knowledge.


Can we see that now is not the time to be extending carbon and methane emitting infrastructure?   


Even without the Bullitt County pipeline extension, Louisville Gas & Electric can and will continue their mission of supplying energy to customers who need it. The existing pipeline services and jobs are not going anywhere in a hurry. There is a natural lifespan of the transition that will likely work out over decades. 


As energy users, we ARE already transitioning to cleaner, better and more efficient technology, and there is great opportunity in transitioning well.  A corporation whose name encompasses both the new electric power and the old fossil fuel is in a good position to do that.


I expect Kentucky needs and wants continued good service provided by LG&E-KU. 




Maggie Hettinger is a volunteer with Citizens’ Climate Lobby, a non-partisan, non-profit, grassroots organization that exists to create the political will for a livable world.


Louisville Gas & Electric (LG&E-KU) and Bernheim Forest are in court dispute over land protection vs. acquisition by eminent domain.  



Published Feb 6, 2023  in Kentucky Standard, Bardstown, KY